Saving lives with fewer discussions - coordination between military and non-military organisations during disaster relief operations
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.29015/cerem.738Keywords:
Disaster relief operations, humanitarian disaster, humanitarian logistics, military and non-military coordinationAbstract
Purpose: This study focusses on the coordination required between military and non-military organisations during humanitarian disasters.
Design / Research methods: An in-depth case study was conducted of the disaster relief operation after hurricane Matthew on Haiti in October 2016. We investigated the support of the Dutch military organization and its coordination with the non-military relief organizations. We examined coordination issues at operational, tactical, and strategic levels.
Findings: The study shows that no coordination problems occurred at operational level. At the tactical level, cultural differences between military and non-military organizations resulted in coordination problems and deviant perspectives on urgency. At the strategic level, there was a disagreement between the Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Dutch Ministry of Defence regarding the Oslo Guidelines. A minority agreed that the guidelines actually apply to military organizations during disaster relief operations.
Practical implications: The coordination between the military organization and the non-military relief organization during disaster relief operations can be improved by promoting common and mutual respect and defining a clear tasks and role fulfilments. A first step to improve the coordination is to get familiarity and clarity on the Oslo Guidelines. Another step for improvement is for the military organization to accept that it has no leading but an assistance role during disaster relief operations.
Research limitations/implications: A single case study limits the external validity of the results, although useful insights were gained. Future research could address the role of the Oslo Guidelines during disaster relief operations. Are these guidelines still valid, should they be updated, and are the sufficiently known by all relief organizations, including the military?
Originality/value of the article: The world is faced with an increasing occurrence of disasters affecting human lives. More lives could be saved when military and non-military organizations would work together more effectively. This is one of the first studies to explore the terms of engagement at the start of relief operations.
References
Ahmadi M., Seifi A., Tootooni B. (2015), A humanitarian logistics model for disaster relief operation considering network failure and standard relief time. A case study on San Francisco district, „Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review”, vol. 75, pp. 145-163.
Allied Administrative Publications (AAP) 06 (2013), NATO Glossary of Terms and Definitions, https://www.academia.edu/10269177/AAP-6_NATO_Glossary_of_Terms_and_Definitions_2013_ [31.05.2019].
Altay N., Green W.G. (2006), OR/MS research in disaster operations management, „European Journal of Operational Research”, vol. 175 no. 1, pp. 475-493.
Altay N., Labonte M. (2014), Challenges in humanitarian information management and exchange. Evidence from Haiti, „Disasters”, vol. 38 no. s1, pp. s50-s72.
Apte A. (2009), Humanitarian logistics. A new field of research and action. Foundations and trends in technology, „Information and Operation Management”, vol. 3 no. 1, pp. 1-100.
Balcik B., Beamon B.M., Krejci C.C., Muramatsu K.M., Ramirez M. (2010), Coordination in humanitarian relief chains. Practices, challenges and opportunities, „International Journal of Production Economics”, vol. 126 no. 1, pp. 22-34.
Barber E. (2012), Military involvement in humanitarian supply chains, in: Relief supply chain management for disaster. Humanitarian aid and emergency logistics, Kovács G., Spens K. (eds.), IGI Global, Hershey, PA, pp. 123-146.
Bjerge B., Clark N., Fisker P., Raju E. (2016), Technology and information sharing in disaster relief, „PLOS One”, vol. 11 no. 9, pp. 1-20.
Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters (2016), 2015 disaster in numbers, www.cred.be/publications [31.05.2019].
Cozzolino A., Rossi S., Conforti A. (2012), Agile and lean principles in the humanitarian supply chain. The case of the United Nations World Food Programme, „Journal of Humanitarian Logistics and Supply Chain Management”, vol. 2 no. 1, pp. 16-33.
Cross T. (2012), Disaster agencies and military force – not such strange bedfellows after all!, in: Humanitarian logistics. Meeting the challenge of preparing for and responding to disasters, Christopher M., Tatham P. (eds.), Kogan Page, London.
Day J.M., Melnyk S.A., Larson P.D., Davis E.W., Whybark D.C. (2012), Humanitarian and disaster relief supply chains. A matter of life and death, „Journal of Supply Chain Management”, vol. 48 no. 2, pp. 21-36.
Eriksson E. (2009), Knowledge transfer between preparedness and emergency response. A case study, „Disaster Prevention and Management”, vol. 18, no. 2, pp. 162-169.
Fernandez T.E., Suthikarnnarunal N (2011), The main aims of humanitarian, business and military organizations and the resulting possible synergies in logistics, „Lecture Notes in Engineering and Computer Science”, vol. 2194 no. 1, pp. 1141-1143.
Ganguly K., Rai S.S. (2016), Managing the humanitarian relief chain. The Uttarakhand disaster issues, „Journal of Advances in Management Research”, vol. 13 no. 1, pp. 92-111.
Heaslip G. (2011), Challenges of civil military cooperation/coordination in humanitarian relief, in: Relief supply chain management for disasters. Humanitarian aid and emergency logistics, Kovács G., Spens K. (eds.), IGI Global, Hershey, PA, pp. 147-172.
Heaslip G., Barber E. (2014), Using the military in disaster relief. Systemizing challenges and opportunities, „Journal of Humanitarian Logistics and Supply Chain Management”, vol. 4 no. 1, pp. 60-81.
Heaslip G., Sharif A.M., Althonayan A. (2012), Employing a systems-based perspective to the identification of inter-relationships within humanitarian logistics, „International Journal of Production Economics”, vol. 139 no. 2, pp. 377-392.
Hicks E., Pappas G. (2006), Coordinating disaster relief after the South Asia earthquake, „Society and Business Review”, vol. 43 no. 5, pp. 42-50.
Houben, M. (2009), Hurricane alert. Hurricane relief operations in the Caribbean, Maritime Operations Working Paper No. 3.
Jahre M., Jensen L.M. (2010), Coordination in humanitarian logistics through clusters, „International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management”, vol. 40 no. 8/9, pp. 657-674.
Jensen L-M., Hertz S. (2016), The coordination roles of relief organisations in humanitarian logistics, „Journal of Logistics Research and Applications”, vol. 19 no. 5, pp. 465-485.
Kovács G., Spens K.M. (2007), Humanitarian logistics in disaster relief operations, „International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management”, vol. 37 no. 2, pp. 99-114.
Kovács G., Spens, K.M. (2009), Identifying challenges in humanitarian logistics, „International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management”, vol. 39, no. 6, pp. 506-528.
Kovács G., Spens K.M. (2011), Trends and developments in humanitarian logistics – a gap analysis, „International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management”, vol. 41 no. 1, pp. 32-45.
Kovács, G., Tatham P.H. (2009), Responding to disruptions in the supply network. From dormant to action, „Journal of Business Logistics”, vol. 30 no. 2, pp. 215-229.
Leiras A., de Brito I. Jr, Peres E.Q., Bertazzo T.R., Yoshizaki H.T.Y. (2014), Literature review of humanitarian logistics research. Trends and challenges, „Journal of Humanitarian Logistics and Supply Chain Management”, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 95-130.
Listou T. (2011), How to supply a frigate, „International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management”, vol. 43 no. 2, pp. 134-147.
McLachlin R., Larson P.D. (2011), Building humanitarian supply chain relationships. Lessons from leading practitioners, „Journal of Humanitarian Logistics and Supply Chain Management”, vol. 1 no. 1, pp. 32-49.
Moshtari M., Gonçalves P. (2016), Factors influencing interorganizational collaboration within a disaster relief context, „Voluntas. International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations”, vol. 28 no. 4, pp. 1673-1694.
Nolte I.M., Martin E.C., Boenigk S. (2012), Cross-sectorial coordination of disaster relief, „Public Management Review”, vol. 14 no. 6, pp. 707-730.
Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) (2007), Oslo Guidelines, guidelines of the use of foreign military and civil defence assets in disaster relief, The Publishing Service, United Nations, Geneva.
Oloruntoba R. (2005), A wave of destruction and the waves of relief. Issues, challenges and strategies, „Disaster Prevention and Management”, vol. 14, pp. 506-521.
Paschal M.D. (2012), Getting beyond “good enough” in contingency contracting by using public procurement law as a force to fight corruption, „Contracting and Military Operations”, vol. 213, pp. 65-139.
Pettit S., Beresford A. (2005), Emergency relief logistics. An evaluation of military, non-military and composite response models, „International Journal of Logistics: Research and Applications”, vol. 8 no. 4, pp. 313-331.
Pettit S., Beresford A. (2009), Critical success factors in the context of humanitarian aid supply chains, „International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management”, vol. 39 no. 6, pp. 450-468.
Rietjes S.J.H. (2008), Managing civil-military cooperation: experiences from the Dutch provincial reconstruction team in Afghanistan, „Armed Forces & Society”, vol. 34 no. 2, pp. 173-207.
Rietjens S.J.H., Voordijk H., De Boer S.J. (2007), Coordinating humanitarian operations in peace support missions, „Disaster Prevention and Management”, vol. 16 no. 1, pp. 56-69.
Rowley J. (2002), using case studies in research, „Management Research News”, vol. 25 no. 1, pp. 16-27.
Rutner S., Avelis M., Cox S. (2012), Logistic evolution. A comparison of military and commercial logistic thought, „The International Journal of Logistics Management”, vol. 23 no. 1, pp. 96-118.
Schultz S.F., Blecken A. (2010), Horizontal cooperation in disaster relief logistics. Benefits and impediments, „International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management”, vol. 40 no. 8/9, pp. 636-656.
Schulz S.F., Heigh I. (2009), Logistics performance management in action within a humanitarian organization, „Management Research News”, vol. 32 no. 11, pp. 1038-1049.
Simatupang T.M., Victoria Sandroto I., Lubis H.S.B. (2004), Supply chain coordination in a fashion firm, „Supply Chain Management: An International Journal”, vol. 9 no. 3, pp. 256-268.
Tatham P., Houghton L. (2011), The wicked problem of humanitarian logistics and disaster relief aid, „Journal of Humanitarian Logistics and Supply Chain Management”, vol. 1 no. 1, pp. 15-31.
Tatham P.H., Pettit S.J. (2010), Transforming humanitarian logistics. The journey to supply network management, „International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management”, vol. 40, no. 8/9, pp. 609-622.
Tatham P., Rietjens S. (2016), Integrated disaster relief logistics: a stepping stone towards viable civil-military networks?, „Disasters”, vol. 40 no. 1, pp. 7-25.
Thomas A., Kopczak L. (2005), From logistics to supply chain management. The path forward in the humanitarian sector, Fritz Institute, www.fritzinstitute.org/PDFs/WhitePaper/FromLogisticsto.pdf [25.01.2017].
Thomas A., Mizushima M. (2006), Logistics training. Necessity or luxury?, „Forced Migration Review”, no. 22, pp. 60-61.
Thompson W.C. (2010), Success in Kashmir. A positive trend in civil-military integration during humanitarian assistance operations, „Disasters”, vol. 34 no. 1, pp. 1-15.
UN/ISDR (2004), Living with risk. A global review of disaster reduction initiatives, https://www.unisdr.org/files/657_lwr1.pdf [31.05.2019].
Van Schoorl M. (2012), Natural disaster response in urban context, Final thesis MBA – Transport and Supply Chain Management”.
Van Staa A.L., Evers J. (2010), Thick analysis. Strategie om de kwaliteit van kwalitatieve data-analyse te verhogen, „KWALON”, vol. 43 no. 1, pp. 5-12.
Van Wassenhove L.N. (2006), Humanitarian aid logistics. Supply chain management in high gear, „The Journal of Operations Research Society”, vol. 57 no. 7, pp. 475-489.
Vroemen M.W. (2009), Team op vleugels, Kluwer, Deventer.
Völz C. (2005), Humanitarian coordination in Indonesia. An NGO viewpoint, „Forced Migration Review”, Special Issue, July 26-27, pp. 26-28.
Voss C., Tsikriktsis N., Frohlich M. (2002), Case research in operations management, „International Journal of Operations & Production Management”, vol. 22 no. 2, pp. 196-219.
Yin R.K. (2009), Case study research: design and methods, 4th edition, SAGE Publications, London.
Yin R.K. (2013), Case study research design and methods, 5th edition, SAGE Publications, London.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
The aim of CEREM is to make scientific work available in accordance with the principle of open access. The rules mentioned below are important, as they enable CEREM and its publisher, the WSB Merito University in Wroclaw, to distribute the scientific work to a wide public while complying with specific legal requirements, at the same time protecting the rights of the authors.
The author transfers to the WSB Merito University in Wroclaw, free of charge and without territorial limitations, with all proprietary copyrights to the said piece of work in the understanding of the act of 4th February 1994 on copyrights and derivative rights (Journal of Laws of 1994, no. 24, item 83, as amended) on an exclusivity basis, i.e. the rights to:
1. Make the piece of work in question available via the Digital Library established by the WSB Merito University in Wroclaw.
2. Produce, record and reproduce in multiple copies the piece of work using any techniques whatsoever, including printing, reprography, magnetic recording and digital processing, and particularly its reproduction by recording on CDs and similar data carriers,
3. Use fragments of the piece of work for promotional purposes in publications, promotional materials, the Internet and Intranet type networks managed by the WSB Merito University in Wroclaw.
4. Store the piece of work into computer databases managed by the WSB Merito University in Wroclaw.
5. Copy and reproduce the piece of work using photo-mechanic technologies other than those commonly known at the time of the signature hereof (photocopies, Xerox copies etc.),
6. Process the piece of work, transferring it into an electronic form, and distribute it on the Internet without limitations.
